Archive for June, 2009

The Rabbi & The Green Goat – a China adapted version

goat-1

(This story reads better in Yiddish, or so I’m told)

An old European-Jewish fable tells about a poor man in a small town who came to see the town’s Rabbi for advice.

“Rabbi” the man said, “My children are many, my wife is pregnant again, I have no icome and am very poor, so we all live together in one shabby room. It’s unbearably crowded and I can’t take it anymore. Please advice me what to do to get my family better off”

“I know you have a goat that you keep in your tiny back yard”  The Rabbi answered, “So here is what you should do: take that goat to live with you in that single room”.

The man was surprised and a bit reluctant, but he still wouldn’t dare  countering the Rabbi’s advice, so he did as told

A week later he stormed into the synagogue, knelt down before the Rabbi and begged for help:

“Rabbi, I can’t take it anymore. I tried to follow your advice, but now my house is even more crowded. The goat is shitting everywhere, the children can’t sleep, and I can’t find a spot to even sit down at”

“Well then”, said the Rabbi, “Take the goat out of the house”

A week later the Rabbi run into the same poor man in the street.

“How are you, Reb Yehudi”? He asked

“Ah, Rabbi, I am so much better”.

“Did you find a better place to live”?

“Oh no, the old place is just fine. Really spacious now that the goat is out”

***********************

Pretty obvious the Green Dam fiasco will end in this regulation getting quietly scraped off. Guess it’ll make the cinternet (the area confined within the great firewall) look spacious all of a sudden.

Could it be that this is actually the motive behind this idiotic idea? I know it’s far fetched, but I haven’t read or heard a better explanation. Can anyone tell me: What is Green Dam for? It will be impossible to enforce and isn’t likely to have that much impact anyway. Does it really worth all the bad press? and would you please take the goat out already?

,

2 Comments


Down and Out in Shanghai

The buildings are, apparently.

aren’t these images a great metaphor to china itself?  uprooted, toppled on it’s side due to shaky, unreliable foundations, yet strangely intact.

2 Comments


Special 拆 sale
Two days until the advance's deadline

Two days until the advance's deadline

Around Dongsi Lukou, work is about to start on Subway line 6, and shops are being chaied*

all-photos-427

 About a month ago, notice papers were pasted to walls in the neighbourhood, specifing all the buildings that are up for demolition. (most of them in 隆福寺, few on 东四系and 东四南)

This is a commercial area, so mainly shops are being chaied, but quite a few of the shop owners also live in adjacent spaces.

all-photos-432all-photos-426

I asked about compensations: Some said they don’t know yet about compensations,neither when exactly they should leave. One men’s outfit shop owner said he got compensations of 20,000 Yuan  per square meters – all together 400,000 Yuan.

all-photos-460

Haven’t had the time yet to seriously go into this, but what I understand from some residents is, the issue of ownership in the Jing’s old neighbourhood is a big legal headache: Some residents actually own their flats or shops, other reside in government property, and often one space has few unrelated owners, including different Danwei, or work units.

all-photos-444

Some more details, hopefully, next week. Meantime, here are more photos of shops getting rid of stocks, even as the walls come tumbling down around them. There are some really great sales there BTW, but you’ll have to hurry: In 2 days, it’ll all be gone.

all-photos-449

 

all-photos-442

 

all-photos-435

, , ,

No Comments


Food for thought

A quick google news search:

The horrendously tyrannical one hour block of Google.com: 834 news articles

Liu Xiaobo’s arrest report: 472 news articles

Shishou Mass Incident (in which tens of thousands participated: 202 news articles, including some from Xinhua and China daily.

Call me crazy, but I’m just not sure how priorities are being set anymore.

, , ,

2 Comments


With all the other twats…

Few minutes ago, I opened a Twitter account.

Not sure why I did it, and in all honest, am a bit embarrassed. the pretext was, I wanted to write somewhere that Google services are currently unavailable, but come to think of it, I’m not sure why it’s important.

Anyhow, here we have a beautiful demonstration of the Adorable Kitten Theory

Update: Jeremy Goldkorn on Danwei seems to think it outrageous. I tend to agree with everything he says, but i just don’t believe the big G would stay blocked for very long. It happened few months ago, but only lasted an hour or so. Morning will tell whether I’m wrong.

And naturally, another update: Google is back. Everyone can breathe normally. Ah, what would I have done wihtout  Nanny’s little dramas.

, ,

No Comments


Another day, another mass incident

20090621_14

 

In  Hubei this time, at a town called Shishou (石首)

In case you haven’t heard about it yet, here is the odd report in English and a report in Chinese. But, as always, the devil is in the details, and for details one must go to none else than Ronald Soong at ESWN.

The story is really horrific, and sadly all too common: drugs, apparent murder, and a blatant cover-up attempts. The report counts 40,000 protesters, which I believe makes it one of the biggest protests in recent years.

Probably, there will be a backlash from higher authorities. Some officials are likely to get sacked, a family compensated, maybe even a trial (But I wouldn’t hold my breath in anticipation)

One thought springs to mind: How many such stories accure in China every day? How many are being silenced? husshed up? repressed? How many don’t spark any protest at all, or only angers few relatives, easily dispersed by police or local thugs?

Can anyone count them all? Is anyone interested in doing so?

When oh Wen will dead kids become as interesting and important as the block of Youtube?

, , , ,

1 Comment


The New Silk Road

Is the name of a relatively new book by economist Ben Simpfendorfer, describing the tightening relations between China and Arab countries.

I had the privilege of interviewing Ben few weeks ago for Calcalist, and was surprised of how much buzz the piece I wrote caused back home (Israelis are usually see themselves more as producers than consumers of international news stories).  Here is an incomplete translation of the interview.

I left out some historical background on the original silk road, mainly out of laziness. You can read some more on the book’s site and also in this interview  on Evan Osnos New-Yorkers blog.

I mentioned before some signs that China is ready to get more involved in the Mid-East, as part of it’s growing international profile. Personally, I see it as a very positive prospect. I’ve always admired the Chinese common sense, exactly the ingredient we in the Mid-East so badly lack.

 So here goes:

China and the Arabs – a Love Story 

A new book puts the story of emerging China in a new light, telling it from the angle of  China’s relationship with the Middle East. This relationship grow stronger through the activities of investors, diplomats, oil companies, governments, but also tens of thousands of traders and small business owners who together push forward economic connections between the two ends of Asia. All of these together help shifting the centre of the global economy eastward. This shift has far reaching projections on the world economy, on the future of the Middle East and perhaps most of all, on Israel. 

“The rise of China is usually being covered from one perspective alone – that of the relations between China and the US or the EU” explains Ben Simpfendorfer, Chief China economist for RBS and author of the book “The New Silk Road”. “Similarly, the rise of the Arab world is being told from the same perspective, of it’s relationship with the west, and the potential or the risks this rise presents, especially to the US. In the book, I wanted to connect the dots, to examine the relationship between The Far East and the Middle East. I wanted to show how the emergence of these two regions isn’t just parallel, but also interdependent. The exchange of ideas nowadays isn’t happening between East and West anymore, but between East and East”.

Simpfendorfer has been working for major investment banks in Beijing and Hong Kong for the last 9 years, but he started his professional life in the Middle East, as a student of Arabic in Damascus, and was then helping Western Companies to establish business in Syria and Lebanon. By the end of the 90’s, the Oslo agreement collapsed, the region got unstable again and the number of companies interested in investing declined. Simpfendorfer went back to Britain, but did not give up the zeal for studying foreign cultures. When opportunity presented itself, he took up a job in Beijing and started learning Chinese, leaving his Middle Eastern adventure behind.

 

But then, he explains, something strange happened: Parallel to the meteoric rise of China since 2000, the Arab World also got out of a long period of stagnation and showed fast growth figures. Simpfendorfer decided to investigate the connection between those two processes. His conclusions are presented in a book: The New Silk Road: How a rising Arab world is turning away from the west and rediscovering China.

 

 

“In the west, we are used to look at the Sino-Arab connection as oil based, and of course, the Middle East is China’s main oil supplier” He says, “But this story is first and foremost the story of small businesses and business people who build the relationship on the local level. The trade between China and the Arab world is carried out but tens of thousands of small traders like the small importer selling clothing at a Damascus market”.

 

Those traders, Simpfendorfer explains, were pretty much forced to discover China when they got shut out of another major market: After 9/11, traders from Syria, Egypt and other countries found many closed doors in the US. Business people suddenly found it hard to get a visa, and were sometimes even arrested at US airports. Those who based their businesses on the American economy begun looking elsewhere, and they found China, who joined the WTO that same year.

  

“The Muslim minority plays an important role in building this relationship” Simpfendorfer explains. “It seems that the Chinese government encourages the participation of the Chinese-Muslims in trade with the Arab world, because it is a way to get them to participate in the economy and improve their living standard”.

 

 One surprising example is a mosque that was built specifically for Arab Traders in Yiwu. Officially, China is still an atheistic country, and puts limits on it’s citizens freedom of religion, but when the newcomers needed religious services, the local government encouraged the building of a mosque and an Arab school, an act that farther strengthened the motivation of Arab traders to come there for business. Yiwu became a Middle-Eastern hamlet in the heart of China, with the highest concentration of Middle-Eastern restaurants in East-Asia. The rumor on China’s Arabtown drew thousands of Chinese Muslims students of Arabic who came there to work as interpreters.

 

Palestinians from Gaza and the West Bank were among the firsts to discover Yiwu, and they still use the place today as a base to export goods to wealthy Middle Eastern countries like Saudi Arabia or Dubai. Other traders from Egypt, Syria, Yemen and other places bring home from Yiwu not only cheap electronics and one dollar leather belts, but also the news of the new and friendly superpower, and the lessons that can be learned from it.

 

 

Learning, Simpfendorfer explains, is fundamental to this story. Some Middle Eastern countries – especially the poorer ones like Syria and Egypt – are starting to look up to China as a model for economic development. “The governor of a Syrian province, El-Haska, recently visited the Central Chinese province of Hunan” he demonstrates. “He did not go to Shanghai, but to Hunan, which is a poor and rural province, that exports human capital to the industrial hubs of East China. It is interesting because the Syrian province can learn a lot from Hunan. The governor can hear ideas on how to create jobs, how to fight poverty, and how to cooperate with other provinces. In many ways, El-Haska can get more relevant ideas in Hunan than in Washington or London”.

 

Do you think the Syrians are also more open to accept Chinese ideas?

Definitely. China is less antagonizing. Many of the ideas you hear in China are actually western ideas: Opening of the capital market, encouraging foreign investment etc. But China took those ideas, took out the parts it didn’t like, changed them so they better suit a developing country, and it did all this with remarkable success. So if a stock exchange was opened in Damascus this year, I see it as a Chinese influence”.

 

….

 

China is putting much time and effort into the relationship. Chinese women, for example, who are opening businesses in Dubai are portrayed in the Chinese media as national heroines. Studying Arabic in a top university is a fast track to the Chinese diplomatic service, and Arabic speaking Chinese officials or regularly being interviewed on “Al Jazeerah”, answering difficult questions in a way they almost never do on CNN or BBC. Whether justified or not, it seems that the Chinese and Arabs share suspicions and similar complaints towards Europe and the US. This is yet another factor that helps promoting mutual understanding between the two rising powers.

“If we take Syria again” Says Simpfendorfer, “We can say there is the old Syria, with it’s problematic regime, and there is the new Syria, trying to become more economically advanced. The west is totally focused on the old Syria. The Chinese, in sharp contrast, see only the new Syria”.

 

Many in the west, and more in Israel, will probably see this new and intimate relationship as a nightmare come true, but Simpfendorfer insists it is a positive development. “The new silk road can bring more stability to the middle east. I believe the region today needs to focus on economic reforms rather than political ones, and China can play an important role here. The US needs to encourage this trend”

 

And what about Israel? Do we need to encourage Chinese involvement in the area, or should we be threatened by it?

It is important to understand: The Chinese interest in the region is purely economic. It cannot be expected to promote any political interest of any kind. The last thing China wants is a war in the Middle east, that would push oil prices up – and it should be remembered the soon 70% of China’s oil imports will come from the region. The Chinese influence can be a stabilizing one. After all, the Middle East peace process tried for years to focus on politics, and it led you nowhere. Perhaps with the help of the Chinese, the focus can be shifted towards economic interests. I think it worth a try”.

 

 

 

 

 

 

, , ,

No Comments


You get a firewall, you get a firewall, Everybody gets a firewall

6a00d8341c609853ef011570d3f096970b

Pretty funny how things work out. Yesterday morning Loreta Chao broke the story on the Wall Street Journal. It made it’s way here  and here and to hundreds of other publications. Now  here it is now, on the Shaghai Daily website, spinned back into control. A perfect argument for free flow of information if there ever was one.

Few (maybe dumb) questions on the story because the implications really aren’t clear to me:

1. If the software is optional for the end user to install or not, how much control can the government really have? How much more political censorship can be achieved that isn’t in place already today?

The new York Times seems to think there is a great danger:

But free-speech advocates say they fear the new software could make it even more difficult for China’s 300 million Internet users to access uncensored news and information.

and so do many other news stories, focusing on government censorship. But where is the danger exactly? maybe I’m missing something here, being technologically challenged, but even Rebecca Mackinnon, asking all the right questions, failed to make it clear to me. Mackinnon, however, reads the official notice  as ordering the software to be preinstalled.

Just to make clear: I don’t think this regulations is in any way positive. I just don’t understand what’s the big deal and how it changes the current situation.

2. Is it possible for PC manufacturers to challenge these new regulations on the ground that it limits competition? Can companies which sell similar product file a complaint to the TWO or something, thus challenging the argument that it’s all about fighting filthy pornography? Again, just a thought.

3. Why oh Why is that story an international favourite while this one  about a much more severe, clear and immediate repression is largely muffled?

 Ah, right.  It’s not about technology or the Internet. Don’t you sometimes miss the days when tech was unintelligible and computer science people were just nerds?

Update: The wall street journal today quotes people who’ve tried the green dam software:

Seth Young, spokesman for the Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard, said initial testing indicated that the system only blocked pornography and not politically sensitive Web sites. However, he cautioned that the list of blocked sites could be changed in the future.

Still not clear whether installation will be mandatory.

, , , , ,

No Comments


TAM after midnight

In one sentence: A whole bunch of strange creatures, and a surreal atmosphere

 

6-4

00:36 The Very Important Journalists: Came across them on our way to the square, from where they’ve just came back from the danger zone. VIJ (not the one who write the linked post, just to make clear) tell about their detention of whole 15 minutes and how the square itself is completely sealed and of limits for visitor. Wait, isn’t it always closed at night? ummm, it’s definitely closed tonight.

Well guess other nights, people don’t bother so much checking the situation at the square.

00:45 Rickshaw Men: Want riksha? want riksha? Hutong tour? Do you think they’re undercovers? Some 3 police vans, all ready for detainees are parked at the junction of Chizijie and Changan.

00:46 The Laowais: passing us by on the way out, shouting “The party is over”

00:47 The girl in pink: She is sitting on a stone slab right outside the gate of heavenly peace (Tiananmen). Two more police cars, many policemen and plainclothes dudes looking tired and bored, playing with their umbrellas

01:03 The happy family:just at exit of the underpass at the north-east corner, a mother and a girl who look maybe 4 or 5, walking together with another woman. You think they are undercovers? Ummm, dunno, could it be that they are recruits in the battle for defending the harmonious society? One thing I always liked about TAM is the place’s unique way of making everyone completely paranoid even in the best of days. The oddest thing about tonight is how un-odd it is, how completely normal everything seems: policemen, the odd group of tourists, homeless sleeping and a very quiet, deserted, giant patch of concrete.

01:06 The Reader: A very young man under a street lamp north of the square, reading a book. an old place to be reading a book for sure. few steps for him another girl sitting, keeping an eye on two small travel bags, as if she’s waiting for someone. As we look, a policemen approaches the boy, asking for his name and purpose.

01:10 Forty somethingyears old man says hello and starting talking to us in good English. Another, younger man hangs around, maybe listening. “This is a special night, a very special night. I was here 20 years ago, the army came from there (points west) and my friend was killed” . can you tell what happened inside TAM? “Oh, I was not here, I was in Tianjin at the time, but many friends were here. Are you Italians”?

01:15: The good cop : Past the Great Hall of the People, a police car swings toward us. A smiling young policeman, almost endearing in his round face and casual salute, asks to see passports (actually he just said the word “Passports” in English. “We haven’t got them, left’em at the hotel”. He tries again but gives up after realising we don’t speak a word of Chinese, and tells us to go home.

01:22 The uygurs: A Happy throng of Xinjiang youngsters passing by, laughing. They will stay around for a while, taking photos of themselves. I they are secret police, than they are the best so far in terms of secrecy and good cover.

01:30: Forty somethingand his friend are talking with the police near Tiananmen (the gate). Later we will speculate a lot on whether FS was an undercover policeman. Now they stare at us, we stare back, A. decides to go home. Two teenagers on a bicycle filming, dashing aways as soon as one of the umbrella dudes gets near.  

01:40  The Studentis sitting beside the girl in pink, staring. Says he’s from Hebei, came to Beijing just for the day, to be in the square. “No, people don’t remember, but I do”. A car slows down on Changan Avenue, a girl takes a photo then drives off.

01:45 A Police car approaches which implies it’s time to go home. Another smiling policeman speaks Chinese which I pretend not to understand. “Wait a minute” he says and calls for help. The trick of not speaking Chinese normally help to shake off annoying officials but not this time.

01:52 Officer Zhao is an angry law enforcer wearing the strangest plainclothes so far tonight: A wifebeater, showing off very nice arms, and black training pants. No umbrella. He speaks decent English and tries almost comically to sound angry and intimidating.

Passport? It’s at home? Do you know you are breaking the law not carrying a passport?

I did not know that. Sorry (I assume his goal is to intimidate me into going away, which is what I want to do anyway as it’s late and I’m all for remembering tragic events but not to the extent of being sleep deprived on a working day tomorrow, when I’m scheduled for an awesome sushi lunch).

Oh, oh, you didn’t know? really? you didn’t know? how come there are some laws you know and some you don’t? You can choose: I can fine you 500 dollars or send you off with a warning but you’d be fined 1000 dollars if you get caught again.

Almost had in mind to agree to ask for the 500 dollars fine to see how he pulls it off but was too tired to play tricks. Angry Zhao notifies me that journalists should ask for a permit(!) to visit the square. Everyday or just today? Oh, these few days, on other days it’s OK. So much for “Just another day” 

 -So, do you promise to go home now? you promise you didn’t take any photos? You will go straight home? Do you want us to get a taxi for you?

Yes, actually, that will be nice.

02:15 Home

Lesson of the day: If you have troubles getting a taxi in Beijing, try get in trouble with the secret police.

, ,

5 Comments


Memories of the day

Zhang, 24, Beijing

I remember vaguely sound of shootings, and fires in the street. My parents won’t go out. I don’t know what happened exactly, but I don’t think it’s so important now, so many years later. A lot of progress had been made

*

Zhang, 30, Beijing

I remember in my hometown people were shocked that students would do something like that to our soldiers, burn them alive. My parents say, however, that have I been old enough, I would have probably joined the protesters.

*

Zhang, 32, Beijing

Yes, I remember the event but not very clearly. Yes, I think it should be discussed but it can’t be discussed publicly at present. What angers me the most is how people were treated after June 4th. Participants in the events were denied jobs, even persecuted. I think it’s unfair. As for blocking information 20 years later, well, they are control freaks. This is what China has always been. Probably always will be.

*

Zhang, 27, Beijing

I think it’s not being discussed because it’s not yet history. Not enough time has passed. I think the government was right in what it did: they were afraid of the cultural revolution coming back, and chaos taking control.

*

Zhang, 74, Beijing

What is there to talk about? it’s not interesting.

*

Zhang, 35, Beijing

My students now, they hardly know anything about it. I myself have heard stories from older cousins who were students at the time. One of them spent a month in jail simply because his name was identical to that of Liu Xiaobo. Funny, isn’t it?

I think we, the Chinese, don’t want to ponder over painful memories. We don’t do it in our private lives, nor in our national memory.

*

Zhang, 42, former Beida student

I remember. I hope one day I will be able to write all about it

**************************************

These are all bits from real conversations with real people, brought here in their somewhat less than real names, that took place in the last week.

Of all the many, many articles published in the last weeks over the subject, This one by Donald Morrison really nailed it:


Sometimes I want to take the entire State Council by the lapels of their increasingly stylish suits and shake some sense into them. Gentlemen, this is not the way a great power behaves. Afraid of its own shadow. Frightened of its own people. Haunted by an event that took place 20 years ago, one you can’t even blog about without risking your Internet access or your day  job.

Also of interest (if only because it’s another Chinese person’s view): Ai WeiWei 让我们忘记 “let us forget”. Here in English translation by the indispensable China Geeks.

, , ,

2 Comments