Posts Tagged ‘Tiananmen’
“There are many people in the squ@re today”
Posted by: Rachel in Mysteries of the Big Jing on June 4th, 2010
Soon after flower girl’s detention, a policeman asked me if I spoke Chinese, then asked me to wait. Someone who said he was a Xinhua employee volunteered to act as an interpreter between the policemen and myself & another journalist from Japan who was also asked to wait.
I have to say the Gongans were way more polite this time than they were last year. They kept apologizing for keeping us from work. Maybe I’m reading too much into it but they seemed kind of embarrassed to be participating in this charade.
I was photographed from every angle by five or six policemen and red umbrellas, so I waved to the cameras, as celebrities should. After some questioning (How long have you been in China for? Do you have a Chinese assistant? Have you been to the expo?), our documents were taken away for inspection and returned after about ten minutes. We were still near the phalus and while I was waiting I noticed about half a dozen people wearing white approaching the site. Each of them was alone, none was trying any provocation. They just stood there fro few minutes, took a photos, then went away.
It was getting hot under the Beijing sun with no shade around. The police officer commented that I should have brought a parasol (true). I answered that since they seem to have so many parasols, maybe they could just lend me one. Xinhua guy chuckled but Officer pretended he didn’t hear me (I really shouldn’t say these things. It’s not even funny).
About half an hour passed when another officer came back with my passport. He apologized again for the inconvenience, then said we could go but be careful: “There are many people in the square today. If they gather in big groups, accidents can happen”.
Gongans are just full of truisms today.
Red Umbrella Day
Posted by: Rachel in History, Mysteries of the Big Jing on June 4th, 2010
So it’s the 35th of May again, which everyone knows is just like any other day in wonderland… Red Umbrellas, metal detectors, and girls getting arrested for carrying flowers. Perfectlly normal beast
Red Umbrella day: Been to the square before noon. There, also, a day like any other: a lot (I mean A LOT, few hundred people at least) of tour groups who, surprisingly, mostly used identical red parasols and didn’t seem to be doing much tourism.
Urban public space: You get used to it after a while. You stop thinking how bizaar it is to have metal detectors in an entrance to a public square. Security checks were quite severe today and seem to be focused on elderly ladies, who have had every item in their bags scanned and gone through. They don’t hassle foreigners much as far as I could tell. Maybe they know we are all cowards.
Protest? what protest? Outside of the square, a young man of around 18 wearing red-splatted T-Shirt with the digits 1899 was not allowed in. He asked his photo not be taken. Inside: it’s quite difficult to tell which of the visitors are there to commemorate something. A student from Beida with a big backpack: is he a silent protester? a plainclothes policeman? just a tourist? go figure. Two others were a lot more obvious. When I got to the spot near the memorial for the people’s heroes (or whatever that phallic symbol is called), there was one uniformed policeman there filming a young girl wearing white, carrying white roses, and her friend, a boy in a white shirt. They Were filming him back, which seem to have confused him a lot.
It took few minutes for more police (and red umbrellas) to arrive, after which there were few more minutes of arguing, and the girl was dragged into a police van, the guy was more cooperative and walked to the van all by himself (didn’t get photos of the event. It all happened very quickly , but pretty sure there were others around who did). They were then whisked away, supposedly for tea-drinking in an un-disclosed location.
To be continued:Right after the described events, I got busy having my own little annual ritual with the GonganJu. More on that later today.
The more things change the more they stay the same
Posted by: Rachel in History, Mysteries of the Big Jing on May 25th, 2010
It’s this time of the year again. Spring turns into Summer and in the Jing this season means dryness that makes your eyes itchy and memories that make them wet. Come to think of it, its not such a bad balance is it? Very harmonious, one might think.
Yet again dissidents are lying low for few weeks, police presence is heightened, censorship tightened. The lucky few gather in the relative safety of their homes to watch some footage from back then. This is the meaning of political activism in China now: Watching documentaries. And twittering.
In Hong Kong, they will march, as they do every year. In the US the usual suspects will dutifully attend a protest outside the Chinese embassy, shouting slogans that bear no meaning to anyone anymore. Around the white hole in the center of this fair city, which is also - according to ancient wisdom – the center of the world, plainclothes policemen will pretend to read the papers, that will all state there are no news today. Such are the summer rites in Jing. Soon students will go on vacation. Soon it will start to rain. Hopefully.
Day Three
Posted by: Rachel in Mysteries of the Big Jing on September 11th, 2009
10.09.2009
08:00 AM
Isn’t this pretty? The tappet on this fence concealing the stage at the square is just so optimistic…
Workers on the way to the site:
Not entirely sure what this van is for. How many different kind of cars the PSB has got?
It’s my party, day 2
Posted by: Rachel in East Vs. West on September 9th, 2009
23 days to go
09.09.2009
7 AM
That old Taitai picking cigarette butts from the little flower patch in front of the monument to the heroes of the people is so cute she needs to get a monument all to herself. I’d bet you anything she’ll be there on the day of days, picking used tissues and other trash right through Hu Jintao’s speech.
OK, I wouldnt bet, but wouldn’t is be nice if she’s there?
It’s my party (and I’ll cry if I want to)
Posted by: Rachel in Mysteries of the Big Jing on September 8th, 2009
The Big Jing is gearing up for the grand 60Th anniversary. Here it how it looks like, hour by hour, for the next 24 days.
September 08th, 6AM
Heading to Tiananmen, I somehow always end up in Zhongshan park. Even when wishing to observe the ever eerie atmosphere at the big white hole, the small green park is more appealing, and seems uninterrupted by any preparation. except of course for the loudspeakers near the south gate, the like of which Douglas Adams once describes as “Resembling Manhattan in both shape and size”. Still, the park’s serenity is somehow stronger, somehow fits better with the backdrop of the old palace, than all the commotion outside.
For some reason, the pavement south of the forbidden city is uneven with many broken or loose tiles, and this isn’t likely to change. I guess you should blame it on all those police cars patrolling there at night.
TAM after midnight
Posted by: Rachel in Mysteries of the Big Jing on June 5th, 2009
In one sentence: A whole bunch of strange creatures, and a surreal atmosphere
6-4
00:36 The Very Important Journalists: Came across them on our way to the square, from where they’ve just came back from the danger zone. VIJ (not the one who write the linked post, just to make clear) tell about their detention of whole 15 minutes and how the square itself is completely sealed and of limits for visitor. Wait, isn’t it always closed at night? ummm, it’s definitely closed tonight.
Well guess other nights, people don’t bother so much checking the situation at the square.
00:45 Rickshaw Men: Want riksha? want riksha? Hutong tour? Do you think they’re undercovers? Some 3 police vans, all ready for detainees are parked at the junction of Chizijie and Changan.
00:46 The Laowais: passing us by on the way out, shouting “The party is over”
00:47 The girl in pink: She is sitting on a stone slab right outside the gate of heavenly peace (Tiananmen). Two more police cars, many policemen and plainclothes dudes looking tired and bored, playing with their umbrellas
01:03 The happy family:just at exit of the underpass at the north-east corner, a mother and a girl who look maybe 4 or 5, walking together with another woman. You think they are undercovers? Ummm, dunno, could it be that they are recruits in the battle for defending the harmonious society? One thing I always liked about TAM is the place’s unique way of making everyone completely paranoid even in the best of days. The oddest thing about tonight is how un-odd it is, how completely normal everything seems: policemen, the odd group of tourists, homeless sleeping and a very quiet, deserted, giant patch of concrete.
01:06 The Reader: A very young man under a street lamp north of the square, reading a book. an old place to be reading a book for sure. few steps for him another girl sitting, keeping an eye on two small travel bags, as if she’s waiting for someone. As we look, a policemen approaches the boy, asking for his name and purpose.
01:10 Forty somethingyears old man says hello and starting talking to us in good English. Another, younger man hangs around, maybe listening. “This is a special night, a very special night. I was here 20 years ago, the army came from there (points west) and my friend was killed” . can you tell what happened inside TAM? “Oh, I was not here, I was in Tianjin at the time, but many friends were here. Are you Italians”?
01:15: The good cop : Past the Great Hall of the People, a police car swings toward us. A smiling young policeman, almost endearing in his round face and casual salute, asks to see passports (actually he just said the word “Passports” in English. “We haven’t got them, left’em at the hotel”. He tries again but gives up after realising we don’t speak a word of Chinese, and tells us to go home.
01:22 The uygurs: A Happy throng of Xinjiang youngsters passing by, laughing. They will stay around for a while, taking photos of themselves. I they are secret police, than they are the best so far in terms of secrecy and good cover.
01:30: Forty somethingand his friend are talking with the police near Tiananmen (the gate). Later we will speculate a lot on whether FS was an undercover policeman. Now they stare at us, we stare back, A. decides to go home. Two teenagers on a bicycle filming, dashing aways as soon as one of the umbrella dudes gets near.
01:40 The Studentis sitting beside the girl in pink, staring. Says he’s from Hebei, came to Beijing just for the day, to be in the square. “No, people don’t remember, but I do”. A car slows down on Changan Avenue, a girl takes a photo then drives off.
01:45 A Police car approaches which implies it’s time to go home. Another smiling policeman speaks Chinese which I pretend not to understand. “Wait a minute” he says and calls for help. The trick of not speaking Chinese normally help to shake off annoying officials but not this time.
01:52 Officer Zhao is an angry law enforcer wearing the strangest plainclothes so far tonight: A wifebeater, showing off very nice arms, and black training pants. No umbrella. He speaks decent English and tries almost comically to sound angry and intimidating.
Passport? It’s at home? Do you know you are breaking the law not carrying a passport?
I did not know that. Sorry (I assume his goal is to intimidate me into going away, which is what I want to do anyway as it’s late and I’m all for remembering tragic events but not to the extent of being sleep deprived on a working day tomorrow, when I’m scheduled for an awesome sushi lunch).
Oh, oh, you didn’t know? really? you didn’t know? how come there are some laws you know and some you don’t? You can choose: I can fine you 500 dollars or send you off with a warning but you’d be fined 1000 dollars if you get caught again.
Almost had in mind to agree to ask for the 500 dollars fine to see how he pulls it off but was too tired to play tricks. Angry Zhao notifies me that journalists should ask for a permit(!) to visit the square. Everyday or just today? Oh, these few days, on other days it’s OK. So much for “Just another day”
-So, do you promise to go home now? you promise you didn’t take any photos? You will go straight home? Do you want us to get a taxi for you?
Yes, actually, that will be nice.
02:15 Home
Lesson of the day: If you have troubles getting a taxi in Beijing, try get in trouble with the secret police.
Memories of the day
Zhang, 24, Beijing
I remember vaguely sound of shootings, and fires in the street. My parents won’t go out. I don’t know what happened exactly, but I don’t think it’s so important now, so many years later. A lot of progress had been made
*
Zhang, 30, Beijing
I remember in my hometown people were shocked that students would do something like that to our soldiers, burn them alive. My parents say, however, that have I been old enough, I would have probably joined the protesters.
*
Zhang, 32, Beijing
Yes, I remember the event but not very clearly. Yes, I think it should be discussed but it can’t be discussed publicly at present. What angers me the most is how people were treated after June 4th. Participants in the events were denied jobs, even persecuted. I think it’s unfair. As for blocking information 20 years later, well, they are control freaks. This is what China has always been. Probably always will be.
*
Zhang, 27, Beijing
I think it’s not being discussed because it’s not yet history. Not enough time has passed. I think the government was right in what it did: they were afraid of the cultural revolution coming back, and chaos taking control.
*
Zhang, 74, Beijing
What is there to talk about? it’s not interesting.
*
Zhang, 35, Beijing
My students now, they hardly know anything about it. I myself have heard stories from older cousins who were students at the time. One of them spent a month in jail simply because his name was identical to that of Liu Xiaobo. Funny, isn’t it?
I think we, the Chinese, don’t want to ponder over painful memories. We don’t do it in our private lives, nor in our national memory.
*
Zhang, 42, former Beida student
I remember. I hope one day I will be able to write all about it
**************************************
These are all bits from real conversations with real people, brought here in their somewhat less than real names, that took place in the last week.
Of all the many, many articles published in the last weeks over the subject, This one by Donald Morrison really nailed it:
Sometimes I want to take the entire State Council by the lapels of their increasingly stylish suits and shake some sense into them. Gentlemen, this is not the way a great power behaves. Afraid of its own shadow. Frightened of its own people. Haunted by an event that took place 20 years ago, one you can’t even blog about without risking your Internet access or your day job.
Also of interest (if only because it’s another Chinese person’s view): Ai WeiWei 让我们忘记 “let us forget”. Here in English translation by the indispensable China Geeks.












